Invasive Species Removal Successes in US Lakes

The most successful invasive species removal programs in US lakes combine early detection, physical removal, and sustained public cooperation, with notable wins against aquatic plants like hydrilla and Eurasian watermilfoil, and animals like nutria and common carp. These programs work best when the invasion is caught before it spreads across the entire lake, and when managers use a mix of methods tailored to the specific species and lake conditions.

Why Invasive Species Are So Hard to Remove

Once an invasive species establishes in a lake, it often has no natural predators or diseases to keep it in check. It can outcompete native species for food and space, alter water quality, and clog infrastructure. The key challenge is that lakes are open systems—water flows in and out, and species can hitchhike on boats, equipment, and wildlife. Removal is rarely a one-time fix; it requires ongoing management and prevention to keep the species from returning.

Case Study: Hydrilla in the Southern US

Hydrilla is a submerged aquatic plant that forms dense mats, choking out native plants and interfering with boating and fishing. In several lakes in Florida and Texas, successful programs have used a combination of herbicide treatments, sterile grass carp, and mechanical harvesting. One of the most notable successes is in Lake Seminole, where a coordinated effort among state agencies and local stakeholders reduced hydrilla coverage significantly over several years. The program worked because it combined early detection with repeated treatments and a public education campaign to prevent new introductions.

Case Study: Eurasian Watermilfoil in Northern Lakes

Eurasian watermilfoil is another problematic plant, found in many lakes across the northern US. Successful removal programs, such as those in Lake Minnetonka in Minnesota, have used suction harvesting, bottom barriers, and selective herbicides. The key to success was a lake-wide monitoring program that mapped infestations each year and prioritized treatment areas. Volunteers played a crucial role in hand-pulling small patches, which prevented the plant from spreading to new bays.

Case Study: Nutria in the Chesapeake Bay

Nutria, a large semi-aquatic rodent, were introduced to the Chesapeake Bay region for fur farming and escaped into the wild. They destroyed marsh habitats by eating the roots of plants, leading to erosion and loss of wildlife habitat. The successful removal program, run by the US Fish and Wildlife Service and state partners, used a combination of trapping and hunting. Over several years, the program declared the area nutria-free, marking one of the few successful eradications of a mammal from a large region. The program’s success was due to intensive trapping efforts and the use of detection dogs to find remaining animals.

Case Study: Common Carp in Lake Wingra

Common carp are a widespread invasive fish that uproot plants and muddy the water. In Lake Wingra, Wisconsin, a removal program used commercial netting and electrofishing to remove a large share of the carp population. The program was successful in reducing carp numbers and improving water clarity, but it required continuous effort because carp can repopulate from surrounding waters. Managers learned that removal must be paired with habitat restoration and barriers to prevent re-invasion.

Key Factors for Success

  • Early detection: Finding the species before it spreads widely makes removal much more feasible.
  • Public involvement: Educating boaters and anglers to clean their equipment prevents new introductions.
  • Integrated approach: Using multiple methods—physical, chemical, biological—reduces the chance of resistance and targets different life stages.
  • Long-term commitment: Removal is rarely a one-year project; sustained funding and monitoring are critical.
  • Adaptive management: Programs that adjust based on monitoring data are more effective than those with fixed plans.

Common Misconceptions

One common misconception is that introducing a natural predator is a quick fix. In reality, biological controls can have unintended effects on native species. For example, grass carp are sterile in most states, but they can still eat native plants and alter the ecosystem. Another misconception is that once a species is removed, the lake is permanently safe. In reality, lakes are constantly at risk of new invasions, so prevention and monitoring must continue indefinitely.

Costs and Funding

Removal programs can be expensive, with costs ranging from thousands to millions of dollars depending on the lake size and species. Funding often comes from state and federal grants, local taxes, and nonprofit organizations. For example, the hydrilla program in Lake Seminole was funded by a combination of state and federal sources. However, the economic cost of doing nothing—lost recreation, property values, and water treatment—can be far higher.

How to Get Involved

Individuals can help prevent the spread of invasive species by cleaning, draining, and drying their boats and gear before moving to a new water body. Many lakes have volunteer monitoring programs where citizens can report sightings of invasive species. Joining a local lake association or watershed group is another way to support removal efforts. If you suspect an invasive species in your lake, report it to your state’s natural resource agency.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most effective method for removing invasive aquatic plants?

There is no single best method; it depends on the plant species, lake size, and water use. For small patches, hand-pulling or bottom barriers work well. For larger infestations, herbicides or biological controls like grass carp are often used. Most successful programs use a combination of methods and monitor the results to adjust their approach.

Can invasive species ever be completely eradicated from a lake?

Yes, but it is rare and usually only possible when the invasion is caught early and the lake is relatively isolated. The nutria eradication in the Chesapeake Bay is a notable example. For most species and lakes, the goal is control, not complete eradication, because the species may persist in small numbers or re-enter from connected waters.

How long does a removal program typically take?

There is no set timeline. Some small-scale removals may take a few years, while larger programs can last a decade or more. For example, the nutria program took several years to declare success. The key is to have a long-term plan and secure funding for ongoing monitoring and maintenance.

Are chemical herbicides safe for swimming and drinking water?

Herbicides used in lakes are regulated and applied by licensed professionals. They are typically approved for aquatic use, but there are restrictions on swimming and water use during and after application. Always check with the local authority for specific guidelines. In general, the risk to humans is low when applied correctly, but it is important to follow posted warnings.

What should I do if I see an invasive species in my lake?

Do not try to remove it yourself, as you might accidentally spread it. Instead, take a photo, note the location, and report it to your state’s natural resource agency or a local lake association. They can verify the species and decide on the appropriate response.