Removing brick shelves above a fireplace can open up the space, allow for a cleaner look, or prepare the wall for a new surround. This guide walks you through the safe removal of three brick shelves, whether they are solid masonry or decorative veneer. Before you start, confirm that the shelves are not load-bearing (they rarely are, but if they tie into the chimney structure, consult a professional). You will also need to protect the floor and yourself from dust and debris.
What You’ll Need
- Safety glasses and a dust mask (or respirator)
- Heavy-duty work gloves
- Masonry chisel (cold chisel) and a small sledgehammer or drilling hammer
- Angle grinder with a diamond blade (for cutting mortar joints)
- Pry bar or wrecking bar
- Shop vacuum with a fine dust filter
- Drop cloths or plastic sheeting
- Scaffolding or a sturdy step ladder (to reach the top shelf safely)
- Bucket for debris
- Optional: masonry saw (for clean cuts) and a hammer drill with a masonry bit
Step-by-Step
- Prepare the area. Clear the fireplace mantel and the floor in front of it. Lay drop cloths or plastic sheeting to catch dust and brick fragments. Open windows for ventilation and set up a fan to blow dust outward.
- Set up safe access. If the shelves are above head height, use a sturdy step ladder or scaffolding. Ensure it is on a level surface and that you can reach the top shelf without overstretching.
- Inspect the shelf construction. Look at the ends of the shelves and the mortar joints. Solid brick shelves are usually laid as part of the chimney or wall, with full mortar joints. Veneer shelves are thinner and may be glued or tied with metal straps. This determines whether you can simply pry them off or need to cut through mortar.
- Score the mortar joints (for solid shelves). Use an angle grinder with a diamond blade to cut along the mortar joints where the shelf meets the wall. Cut on both the top and bottom of each shelf, and at the sides if the shelves are flush with the wall. This weakens the bond and makes chiseling easier.
- Break the mortar with a chisel. Place a cold chisel into the scored joint and tap it with a sledgehammer or drilling hammer. Work along the joint, chipping away the mortar. Do this for all three shelves, starting with the lowest one. Removing the bottom shelf first gives you better access to the ones above.
- Pry the shelf away. Once the mortar is loose, insert a pry bar behind the shelf and gently lever it away from the wall. Work from one end to the other. If the shelf is solid, it may come off in one piece, but be prepared for it to break into a few chunks.
- Remove the middle and top shelves. Repeat the scoring and chiseling process for the middle shelf, then the top shelf. For the top shelf, you may need to work from the side or use a longer pry bar. Always support the shelf as it comes free to prevent it from falling.
- Clean up the wall. After all shelves are removed, you will have rough patches where mortar remains. Use a chisel or a wire brush to remove loose mortar, then vacuum the area thoroughly.
- Patch and refinish. Depending on your plan, you can fill the gaps with mortar or drywall compound, then paint or tile over the area. If the brick is exposed, you may want to leave it as a rustic feature or cover it with a new surround.
Common Mistakes
- Not checking for load-bearing support. If the shelves are part of the chimney structure, removing them could compromise the fireplace. When in doubt, ask a mason or structural engineer.
- Using too much force. Prying aggressively can crack the surrounding brick or damage the wall. Work slowly and let the chisel do the cutting.
- Skipping the scoring step. Trying to chisel out a solid shelf without cutting the mortar joints first is exhausting and can damage the wall.
- Ignoring dust control. Brick dust is fine and gets everywhere. Even with a vacuum, you will have a mess. Wear a mask and seal off doorways with plastic.
- Removing the top shelf first. This can cause debris to fall on you and makes the job harder. Always start at the bottom.
Tips
- If the shelves are veneer (thin brick), you may be able to simply pry them off with a pry bar after cutting any adhesive with a utility knife. Test a corner first.
- Keep a spray bottle of water handy to dampen dust while grinding. This keeps particles from becoming airborne.
- Use a vacuum with a HEPA filter to trap fine brick dust; a regular shop vacuum may just blow it back out.
- If you plan to reuse the bricks, wrap them in cloth as you remove them and clean off old mortar with a wire brush.
- Consider renting a masonry saw if you need very clean cuts, but for removal, an angle grinder is usually sufficient.
Troubleshooting
The shelf won’t budge after chiseling. You may have missed a hidden metal tie or the mortar is harder than expected. Use the angle grinder to cut deeper along the joints, and look for metal straps. If you see metal, cut through it with a grinder or use a reciprocating saw with a metal-cutting blade.
The wall is cracking around the shelf. Stop immediately. This can happen if the shelf is tied into the wall structure. Assess the damage. If the crack is minor, you can patch it later. If it’s significant, consult a professional before proceeding.
You hit a flue or vent. If you see a metal pipe or duct behind the shelf, stop and reassess. You may be near a chimney flue or a heating vent. Do not cut into it. Call a professional to evaluate the situation.
The shelf breaks into pieces while removing. That’s normal. Just continue to chip away the pieces, but be careful not to let large chunks fall. Support the shelf with one hand while prying with the other.
There’s a large gap after removal. If the shelf was built into the wall, you may have a hole that needs patching. Use mortar or patching compound to fill it, then finish with paint or tile.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I remove brick shelves without damaging the fireplace? Yes, if you score the mortar joints and work carefully. Some minor damage to the surrounding brick is possible, but it can be patched.
Do I need a permit to remove brick shelves? Typically no, because they are not structural. But if your fireplace is part of a load-bearing wall, check with your local building department.
Can I reuse the bricks? Yes, if you remove them intact. Clean off old mortar and they can be used for other projects.
What if the shelves are part of the chimney? If they are integral to the chimney structure, removal could be unsafe. Have a professional assess it.
How long does this take? For three shelves, expect a few hours of work, plus time for patching and finishing.
Can I do this alone? Yes, but having a helper is safer, especially for the top shelf.