Blue Eggs: Which Chicken Breeds Lay Them

The chickens that lay blue eggs are breeds carrying a specific genetic mutation that produces a blue pigment called oocyanin. The most common and widely available blue-egg layers are the Araucana, Ameraucana, and Cream Legbar breeds.

What Makes the Egg Blue?

The blue color is not painted on the shell; it is deposited throughout the shell during formation. The pigment oocyanin is produced in the hen’s shell gland and permeates the entire calcium carbonate shell, which is why the blue color is visible both inside and outside. This is different from brown eggs, where the pigment is applied as a final coating, leaving the interior white.

The genetic mutation responsible for blue shells is a retrovirus insertion that affects the expression of a specific gene. This mutation is dominant, meaning that if a hen carries one copy of the blue-egg gene, she will lay blue eggs. The exact shade can vary from a pale sky blue to a deeper turquoise, depending on the breed and individual hen.

Breeds That Lay Blue Eggs

Several breeds are known for their blue eggs. Here are the most recognized:

  • Araucana: Originating from South America, this breed is known for its blue eggs and distinctive tufts of feathers near the ears. They are also rumpless, meaning they lack a tailbone. Araucanas are relatively rare and can be challenging to breed due to a lethal gene associated with the ear tufts.
  • Ameraucana: Developed in the United States from Araucana stock, Ameraucanas have a beard, muffs, and a tail. They lay blue eggs and are often confused with Easter Eggers, which are a mixed breed that can lay blue, green, or pink eggs. True Ameraucanas conform to a breed standard.
  • Cream Legbar: A British breed developed in the early twentieth century, the Cream Legbar is an auto-sexing breed, meaning chicks can be sexed by their down color at hatch. They lay blue or occasionally greenish-blue eggs and are known for their friendly disposition.
  • Other breeds: Some other breeds, such as the Arkansas Blue and the Whiting True Blue, have been developed more recently and also lay blue eggs. These are less common but are gaining popularity among backyard keepers.

How to Choose a Blue-Egg Breed

Selecting the right blue-egg layer depends on your goals, climate, and experience level. Consider the following factors:

  • Egg production: Cream Legbars are generally prolific layers, producing several eggs a week. Ameraucanas are also good layers, while Araucanas may be slightly less productive.
  • Temperament: Ameraucanas are typically calm and friendly, making them good for families. Cream Legbars are active and curious. Araucanas can be flighty and more independent.
  • Hardiness: Araucanas are hardy in cold climates due to their small combs. Cream Legbars have larger combs and may be more susceptible to frostbite in very cold regions.
  • Availability: Ameraucana chicks are widely available from hatcheries. Cream Legbars are becoming more common but may require ordering from specialty breeders. Araucanas are the hardest to find.

Blue Eggs vs. Green Eggs vs. Brown Eggs

It’s easy to confuse blue and green eggs, but the difference is the presence of a brown pigment. Green eggs are laid by hens that carry both the blue-egg gene and the brown-egg gene. The brown pigment is deposited over the blue, resulting in an olive or green hue. Easter Eggers, which are mixed-breed chickens, often lay green eggs because they inherit the blue gene from one parent and the brown gene from the other.

Brown eggs are produced by breeds like Rhode Island Reds and Orpingtons. The brown color is a surface coating, so it can be rubbed off. Blue eggs, in contrast, have the color throughout the shell, so they remain blue even when scraped.

Nutritional Content and Taste

Many people wonder if blue eggs are healthier or taste different. Nutritionally, blue eggs are essentially identical to white or brown eggs. The shell color has no effect on the yolk, albumen, or nutritional profile. The taste is also the same, assuming the hens are fed the same diet. The perceived difference in taste often comes from the hen’s diet, not the shell color. Hens that forage on grass and insects produce eggs with a richer flavor and deeper orange yolks, regardless of shell color.

Common Misconceptions and Problems

One common misconception is that blue eggs are a sign of a rare or exotic breed. While the specific breeds are less common, the gene itself is not rare. Another misconception is that blue eggs have a stronger shell. The shell strength is determined by the hen’s diet and health, not the color.

A practical problem with blue-egg breeds is that some, like the Araucana, have a high rate of embryo mortality due to the same genetic mutation that creates the ear tufts. This makes them harder to breed and more expensive to purchase. Additionally, some blue-egg layers, particularly Cream Legbars, can be flighty and may try to fly over fences, so secure housing is essential.

Cost and Availability

Blue-egg layers are generally more expensive than standard brown-egg layers. Chicks from hatcheries may cost a few dollars more per bird. Adult hens from specialty breeders can be significantly more expensive, especially if they are from show-quality lines. The availability varies by region and season. Hatcheries often sell out of popular blue-egg breeds early in the spring, so it’s wise to order several months in advance.

Alternatives to Blue-Egg Chickens

If you want colorful eggs but are not set on blue, consider these alternatives:

  • Easter Eggers: These mixed-breed chickens lay a variety of colors, including blue, green, and sometimes pink. They are hardy, friendly, and widely available.
  • Olive Eggers: A cross between a blue-egg layer and a dark brown-egg layer, producing olive-green eggs. They are popular for their unique color.
  • Dark brown egg layers: Breeds like Marans and Welsummers lay very dark brown eggs, which can be just as striking as blue.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do all Araucanas lay blue eggs? Yes, purebred Araucanas lay blue eggs. However, many birds sold as Araucanas are actually Easter Eggers, which may lay green or other colors. If you want true Araucanas, purchase from a reputable breeder who can verify the lineage.

Can I tell if a hen will lay blue eggs before she starts laying? No, you cannot tell by looking at the hen. The only reliable way is to know the breed and lineage. Some breeds, like Cream Legbars, are auto-sexing, so you can tell the sex of chicks, but not the egg color.

Are blue eggs safe to eat? Yes, blue eggs are perfectly safe to eat. They are just like any other chicken egg, with the same nutritional value and safety considerations. Always handle and cook eggs properly.

Why are my hen’s blue eggs turning lighter or darker? The shade of blue can vary from egg to egg and may fade as the laying season progresses. Stress, diet, and the hen’s age can affect the intensity of the color. This is normal and not a cause for concern.

Can I breed a blue-egg layer with a brown-egg layer? Yes, you can. The resulting offspring will carry the blue-egg gene. If they also inherit the brown-egg gene, they will lay green eggs. If not, they will lay blue eggs. This is how Easter Eggers and Olive Eggers are created.

Summary

Blue eggs come from a handful of chicken breeds that carry a specific genetic trait. The Araucana, Ameraucana, and Cream Legbar are the most recognized, but others exist. The color is embedded in the shell, making it unique among egg colors. While blue eggs are not nutritionally different, they are a fun and beautiful addition to any flock. When choosing a breed, consider your climate, space, and the bird’s temperament. With proper care, these hens will reward you with a steady supply of stunning blue eggs.