The best plants to grow around trees are shallow-rooted, shade-tolerant species that can thrive in dry soil and compete with tree roots for water and nutrients. Choose plants that match the specific light, moisture, and soil conditions under your tree, and avoid disturbing the tree’s root system.
Why Planting Under Trees Is Tricky
Tree roots are not just deep underground; most of them are in the top foot or two of soil, spreading far beyond the canopy. These roots compete fiercely with anything you plant beneath them for water and nutrients. Additionally, the canopy blocks sunlight, and the soil under a tree often stays dry because the tree intercepts rain. This combination of shade, dryness, and root competition makes the area under a tree a challenging environment for many garden plants.
Another issue is soil compaction. The soil under a tree is often packed down from foot traffic, lawn mowing, or the weight of the tree itself. Compacted soil has poor aeration and drainage, which further stresses new plants. Understanding these challenges is the first step to choosing plants that will actually survive.
How Tree Roots Affect Your Planting Choices
Tree roots are not all the same. Some trees, like maples and elms, have dense, shallow root systems that cover a wide area. Others, like oaks and pines, have a deeper taproot with fewer surface roots. The type of tree you have will influence what you can plant and how you should plant it.
When you dig a hole under a tree, you risk cutting roots that are essential for the tree’s health. Cutting large roots can destabilize the tree or allow diseases to enter. Therefore, you should never dig deep or wide holes directly under the canopy. Instead, use small hand tools and plant individual specimens in small holes, or simply place plants on top of the soil and cover them with mulch.
Choosing the Right Plants: Light, Moisture, and Soil
Before you buy anything, observe the area under your tree at different times of day. Is it in full shade, partial shade, or does it get some direct sun? Also, check the soil moisture. Is it bone dry even after rain? The answers will guide your plant selection.
For dry shade, which is common under large trees, choose plants that are drought-tolerant and can handle root competition. For moist shade, you have more options, but still need to avoid plants that require rich, loose soil. Always amend the soil with compost when planting, but do so gently, without disturbing tree roots.
Top Plant Choices for Under Trees
Here are some reliable plants that generally do well under trees, grouped by their characteristics:
- Groundcovers: Wild ginger, foamflower, and sweet woodruff are excellent for covering bare soil. They spread slowly and tolerate shade.
- Perennials: Hostas, ferns, and bleeding hearts are classic shade lovers. They come in many sizes and colors, and their shallow roots are less likely to conflict with tree roots.
- Bulbs: Spring bulbs like daffodils, snowdrops, and crocuses are perfect because they bloom early before the tree leafs out, and they go dormant by summer, avoiding the dry period.
- Shrubs: For a more substantial presence, consider shade-tolerant shrubs like hydrangeas, azaleas, or rhododendrons, but only if the area is large enough and the tree roots are not too dense.
Always check the specific growing requirements for each plant. Some ferns, for example, prefer moist soil, while others are drought-tolerant. Matching the plant to your specific conditions is more important than any generic list.
How to Plant Under a Tree Without Damaging Roots
Planting under a tree requires a gentle touch. Follow these steps to minimize root disturbance:
- Choose small, young plants that require less digging.
- Use a hand trowel or a small spade to dig individual holes, not a large bed.
- Dig only as deep as the root ball of the plant, and make the hole slightly wider.
- If you encounter a thick root, move the hole a few inches to the side rather than cutting it.
- Backfill with the original soil mixed with a little compost, and water thoroughly.
- Apply a layer of mulch, but keep it a few inches away from the tree trunk.
This method preserves the tree’s root system while giving your new plants a fighting chance. Avoid creating a raised bed over the tree roots, as this can smother them and cause the tree to decline.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
One of the most common mistakes is building a raised bed under a tree. Piling soil over the roots can suffocate them, leading to the tree’s death over several years. Another mistake is choosing sun-loving plants that will struggle in the shade. They may survive for a season but will eventually weaken and die.
Overwatering is also a problem. Many people water their new plants frequently, but the tree’s roots are also taking up water. This can lead to waterlogged soil, which is harmful to both the tree and the new plants. Instead, water deeply but less frequently, and check the soil moisture before watering.
Finally, avoid using heavy machinery or tilling under the tree. This can severely damage roots and compact the soil, creating a long-term problem.
Alternatives to Planting: Mulch and Hardscaping
If planting seems too risky or the area is too shady and dry, consider alternatives. A thick layer of mulch (wood chips, shredded bark, or leaf mold) can cover the bare soil, suppress weeds, and retain moisture. This is often the best option for the tree’s health.
You can also create a seating area or a path under the tree using gravel, pavers, or stepping stones. This eliminates the need for plants entirely and can be a beautiful, low-maintenance solution. Just be sure to use a permeable material so water can still reach the tree roots.
Costs and Maintenance Considerations
The cost of planting under a tree varies widely depending on the plants you choose. Small perennials and groundcovers are inexpensive, while shrubs and larger specimens cost more. You will also need to invest in soil amendments, mulch, and possibly a drip irrigation system to keep the new plants watered during their first year.
Maintenance is relatively low once the plants are established. You will need to water during dry spells, especially in the first year, and replenish mulch annually. You may also need to divide or thin out plants as they spread. Overall, the effort is modest compared to the visual improvement it brings to your landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I plant grass under a tree?
Grass is one of the hardest things to grow under a tree because it needs full sun and ample water, both of which are scarce under a canopy. If you want a lawn, consider a shade-tolerant grass mix, but be prepared for it to be thin and patchy. Often, a groundcover or mulch is a better choice.
How close to the trunk can I plant?
You should avoid planting within a foot or two of the trunk, as the soil there is often dry and the roots are thick. The area near the trunk is also prone to rot if you pile mulch or soil against it. Keep a clear zone around the trunk to protect the tree’s health.
What if I have a tree with aggressive surface roots?
If your tree has aggressive surface roots, such as a maple or willow, planting directly under it is very difficult. Your best bet is to use a thick layer of mulch or create a hardscape feature. If you must plant, choose very small, shallow-rooted plants and place them in the spaces between roots.
Are there any plants that are toxic to trees?
No plants are inherently toxic to trees, but some plants, like English ivy, can climb the trunk and smother the tree. Also, plants that require heavy watering or fertilizing can harm a tree by encouraging shallow root growth or causing nutrient imbalances. Stick to plants that have similar needs to the tree.
When is the best time to plant under a tree?
Early spring or fall is the best time to plant under a tree, as the weather is cooler and there is usually more moisture. Avoid planting in the heat of summer, as the new plants will struggle to establish. Watering consistently during the first growing season is crucial.
Summary
Growing plants under a tree is possible if you choose the right plants and plant them carefully. Focus on shallow-rooted, shade-tolerant species, avoid disturbing tree roots, and be prepared to water and mulch. If conditions are too harsh, mulch or hardscaping are excellent alternatives that protect the tree and look good. With a little planning, you can turn the bare ground under your tree into a thriving garden.