Maple and cherry are two of the most popular hardwoods for furniture, cabinetry, and flooring, but they differ significantly in color, grain, hardness, and how they age. Maple is a pale, very hard, and subtle-grained wood that resists wear, while cherry is a warm, reddish-brown wood with a smooth, fine grain that darkens beautifully over time.
What Is Maple Wood?
Maple comes from several species of the Acer genus, with hard maple (often called rock maple or sugar maple) being the most common for furniture and flooring. It is a dense, heavy wood with a fine, uniform texture and a subtle, often wavy grain. The sapwood is nearly white to light cream, while the heartwood is a light reddish-brown. Maple is prized for its durability and resistance to impact, making it a top choice for butcher blocks, cutting boards, and high-traffic flooring. It also takes stain and paint well, though its tight grain can sometimes appear blotchy when stained, so many woodworkers use a pre-conditioner.
What Is Cherry Wood?
Cherry (American black cherry, Prunus serotina) is a hardwood native to eastern North America. Its heartwood ranges from a light pinkish-brown to a rich reddish-brown, often with a golden sheen. The grain is typically straight and fine, with a smooth, satiny texture. Cherry is softer than maple but still durable enough for most furniture. Its most distinctive trait is how it ages: exposure to light darkens the wood from a pale pink to a deep, warm mahogany-like brown over several months or years. This natural color change is a major reason people choose cherry, as the wood develops a rich patina that many find more beautiful than its initial appearance.
Hardness and Durability
On the Janka hardness scale, which measures resistance to denting and wear, hard maple scores significantly higher than cherry. Maple is one of the hardest domestic woods, while cherry is comparatively soft—about as hard as walnut or black walnut. In practical terms, maple is better for surfaces that take a lot of abuse, like countertops, stair treads, and children’s furniture. Cherry is more prone to dents and scratches, so it’s better suited for formal dining tables, bedroom furniture, and pieces that won’t see heavy daily wear. However, cherry’s softness also makes it easier to work with hand tools and carve, which is why it’s a favorite among furniture makers for detailed joinery and moldings.
Appearance and Aging
The most obvious difference is color. Maple starts pale and stays relatively light, though it can amber slightly with age. Cherry starts pinkish and darkens dramatically to a rich reddish-brown. This darkening is caused by UV light and oxidation, and it’s not uniform—areas exposed to sunlight will darken faster than shaded parts. If you place a book on a cherry table, the covered spot will remain lighter for a while. This is a natural process, and many people love it, but if you want a consistent color, you’ll need to expose all surfaces to light evenly during the first few months. Maple’s color change is minimal, so it’s easier to match new pieces to existing ones.
Grain and Texture
Maple has a fine, uniform grain that is often described as subtle or even bland. It can feature interesting figures like bird’s-eye, curly, or quilted patterns, which are highly prized for decorative panels. Cherry’s grain is also fine and straight, but it’s more pronounced than maple’s, with occasional mineral streaks and small gum pockets. Cherry’s texture is smooth and even, making it excellent for carving and turning. When finished, cherry often has a silky, lustrous appearance, while maple can look more matte or glossy depending on the finish.
Workability and Finishing
Both woods are relatively easy to work with, but they have different quirks. Maple’s hardness makes it tough on tools; it can burn if you use dull blades or feed too slowly. It also has a tendency to blotch when stained, so many woodworkers use a gel stain or a pre-stain conditioner. Cherry is softer and easier to cut, but it can burn too, and it’s prone to blotching as well. However, cherry takes oil-based finishes beautifully, and many people simply use a clear finish to let the natural color develop. Maple’s light color makes it a great canvas for paint or opaque finishes, while cherry is almost always used with a transparent finish to show off its color.
Cost and Availability
Both maple and cherry are widely available in North America, but cherry is generally more expensive than hard maple. The price difference can vary by region and market, but cherry is often priced at a premium because of its popularity and the fact that it’s less abundant than maple. Maple is plentiful and often used for lower-cost furniture, though figured maple (like bird’s-eye) can be pricey. If you’re on a budget, maple is usually the more affordable option, while cherry is a step up in cost.
Common Uses
Maple’s hardness and light color make it ideal for:
- Butcher blocks and cutting boards
- Kitchen countertops and islands
- Flooring (especially in high-traffic areas)
- Children’s furniture and toys
- Baseball bats and bowling pins (though not for home use)
Cherry’s beauty and workability make it perfect for:
- Fine furniture, like dining tables and bedroom sets
- Cabinetry and built-in bookshelves
- Musical instruments, such as guitars and pianos
- Woodturning and carving projects
- Architectural millwork and paneling
Which One Should You Choose?
Your choice depends on your priorities. If you want a light, durable surface that can handle heavy use, maple is the clear winner. If you want a warm, rich color that will deepen with age and you don’t mind a few dents, cherry is a beautiful choice. Consider the room’s lighting, the style of your home, and how the piece will be used. For example, a maple kitchen island will stay bright and resist scratches, while a cherry dining table will become the warm focal point of the room. Also, think about future repairs: maple’s light color makes nicks and scratches less visible, while cherry’s darkening can make repairs tricky if you need to match the aged color.
Common Misconceptions
One common myth is that cherry is too soft for any furniture. While it’s softer than maple, it’s still a hardwood and is used for heirloom-quality pieces that last generations. Another misconception is that maple is always plain and boring—figured maple is anything but. Also, people often think that cherry’s darkening is a defect; it’s actually a prized feature. Finally, some assume that all maple is the same, but soft maple (like silver maple) is much less durable than hard maple, so always ask which species you’re getting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does cherry wood darken significantly?
Yes, cherry darkens dramatically over time. A new cherry piece may look pale pink, but within a few months to a year, it will turn a rich reddish-brown. This is due to UV light and oxidation, and it’s a natural process that many people love. If you want to slow it down, you can use a UV-blocking finish, but it won’t stop it entirely.
Is maple or cherry better for kitchen cabinets?
Both are good, but maple is more durable and resistant to moisture and scratches, making it a practical choice for busy kitchens. Cherry is softer and can dent, but it’s also very popular for its warm color. If you have a traditional or rustic kitchen, cherry’s patina might be perfect; if you want a modern, light look, maple is a better fit.
Can I stain maple to look like cherry?
Yes, you can stain maple to mimic cherry’s color, but it won’t have the same depth or grain. Maple’s tight grain will take the stain differently, and it may look blotchy unless you use a pre-stain conditioner. Also, maple won’t darken over time like real cherry, so the color will stay more static.
Which wood is more expensive, maple or cherry?
Cherry is generally more expensive than hard maple, though prices vary by region and quality. Figured maple can be more expensive than plain cherry, but for standard lumber, cherry commands a premium. If budget is a concern, maple is usually the more affordable choice.
Is cherry wood good for cutting boards?
Cherry is a good cutting board material because it’s hard enough to resist deep cuts, but it’s not as hard as maple, so it may show knife marks more easily. Maple is the classic choice for cutting boards because it’s very hard and has a tight grain that resists bacteria. Both are fine, but maple is more traditional for kitchen use.
How do I tell maple and cherry apart?
Look at the color and grain. Maple is pale cream to light brown, with a subtle, often straight grain. Cherry is pinkish-red to reddish-brown, with a more pronounced, sometimes wavy grain. If you see a piece that’s been exposed to light, cherry will be darker. You can also check the weight: maple is heavier and denser than cherry.
In summary, maple and cherry are both excellent woods, but they serve different purposes. Maple is the workhorse—hard, light, and durable. Cherry is the beauty—warm, rich, and ever-changing. Choose based on your needs, your style, and how you want the piece to age.