Common Gardening Myths: True or False?

Many common gardening myths are false, but a surprising number contain a kernel of truth when you look at the underlying science. This article separates fact from folklore, explaining which popular beliefs hold up and which can actually harm your plants.

Why Gardening Myths Persist

Gardening advice often spreads by word of mouth, passed from neighbor to neighbor or from grandparents to grandchildren. Unlike many other hobbies, gardening has deep roots in tradition, and people tend to trust methods that have been used for generations. However, the reasons behind old practices are sometimes lost, and the advice becomes oversimplified or distorted over time.

Another reason myths persist is that plants are forgiving. A practice that is less than ideal may still produce decent results, especially with hardy species. If you water at noon on a hot day, the plant might wilt temporarily, but it usually recovers. This makes it hard to notice when a piece of advice is wrong, because the consequences are not immediate or dramatic.

Marketing also plays a role. Companies selling soil amendments, fertilizers, or pest control products have an interest in convincing you that you need their product. Some myths, like the idea that you must remove every last fallen leaf, benefit the makers of leaf blowers and lawn bags more than they benefit your garden.

Myth: Watering at Noon Burns Leaves

This is one of the most widespread claims: that water droplets on leaves act like tiny magnifying glasses, focusing sunlight and scorching the foliage. In reality, water droplets are not shaped like perfect lenses, and they evaporate quickly on a hot day. The sun’s rays scatter when they pass through a drop, so they do not concentrate enough energy to burn a leaf.

However, watering at midday is still not a great idea, but for a different reason. Much of the water evaporates before it reaches the roots, so you waste water and may not hydrate the plant thoroughly. The best time to water is early morning, when the air is cool and the wind is calm, allowing water to soak into the soil. Late afternoon is the second-best choice, but avoid evening watering if you can, because foliage that stays wet overnight is more susceptible to fungal diseases.

If you have no choice but to water at noon, it is better than not watering at all, especially for container plants and newly planted seedlings. Just aim the water at the base of the plant rather than spraying the leaves.

Myth: Add Sand to Clay Soil to Improve Drainage

This myth sounds logical: clay soil drains poorly, so adding sand should loosen it up. In practice, mixing sand into clay can create something closer to concrete. Tiny clay particles fill the spaces between sand grains, making the soil even denser and harder for roots to penetrate.

To improve clay soil, the better approach is to add organic matter, such as compost, leaf mold, or well-rotted manure. Organic matter binds clay particles into larger crumbs, creating pore spaces for air and water. It also feeds beneficial microorganisms that further improve soil structure. Work in several inches of compost each season, and over time the soil will become more friable.

If you have sandy soil that drains too quickly, organic matter helps there too, because it holds moisture and nutrients. In both cases, compost is the all-purpose fix, not sand.

Myth: Eggshells Deter Slugs and Snails

Crushed eggshells are often recommended as a barrier against slugs and snails, because the sharp edges are supposed to cut their soft bodies. While this works in theory, in practice the shells must be very sharp and dry. Once they get wet, they lose their edge, and slugs can crawl over them without harm.

If you want to use eggshells, you need to crush them into fine, sharp shards and reapply them after every rain. Even then, a determined slug will find a way around. A more reliable method is to hand-pick slugs at night, set out traps with beer in shallow containers, or use iron phosphate bait, which is safe for pets and wildlife when used as directed.

Eggshells do have a legitimate use in the garden: they add calcium to the soil as they break down. You can crush them and add them to your compost pile, but do not expect them to solve your slug problem.

Myth: You Must Stake Every Tomato Plant

Many gardeners believe that all tomatoes need staking or caging, but this is not true. Determinate varieties, which grow to a fixed size and ripen their fruit all at once, are often grown successfully without support. They tend to be bushier and more compact, so they can hold themselves upright, especially if you mulch underneath to keep fruit off the soil.

Indeterminate varieties, on the other hand, keep growing and producing until frost, and they can become tall and sprawling. These benefit from staking, caging, or trellising to keep the fruit clean and to make harvesting easier. Some gardeners also use the “Florida weave” method, where twine is strung between posts to support the plants.

If you choose not to stake, you should give the plants more space to spread, and you may lose some fruit to rot if it sits on damp ground. The choice depends on the variety and your garden layout.

Myth: Coffee Grounds Make Soil More Acidic

Coffee grounds are often touted as a way to acidify soil for acid-loving plants like blueberries and azaleas. While fresh, unbrewed coffee grounds are acidic, the grounds you use to make coffee have been mostly neutralized. The brewing process extracts most of the acid, so used grounds are close to neutral in pH.

That said, used coffee grounds are still a good addition to the garden. They add organic matter, improve soil structure, and provide a small amount of nitrogen as they decompose. You can add them to your compost pile or spread them thinly around plants. But if you need to lower soil pH, use elemental sulfur or an acidifying fertilizer, and test your soil first to know what you actually need.

Myth: Watering with Ice Cubes Is Good for Houseplants

This myth is popular with people who want to water their orchids or other houseplants slowly. The idea is that ice cubes melt gradually, giving the plant a slow drink. While it is true that slow watering is better than a sudden flood, ice cubes are not ideal for most plants.

Cold water can shock tropical plants, which are used to warm soil. Also, ice cubes deliver water only to a small area, leaving the rest of the root ball dry. Most houseplants prefer water at room temperature, applied evenly over the soil surface until it runs out the drainage holes.

If you have an orchid in bark, ice cubes may not provide enough water, because the bark does not hold moisture well. Instead, water thoroughly and let the pot drain completely. For most houseplants, a regular watering schedule based on checking the soil moisture is the best approach.

Myth: Epsom Salt Makes Plants Grow Better

Epsom salt is magnesium sulfate, and magnesium is an essential nutrient for plants, as it is the core of the chlorophyll molecule. However, most soils have enough magnesium for plant needs. Adding more does not help unless your soil is actually deficient.

Some gardeners swear by Epsom salt for tomatoes and peppers, claiming it prevents blossom end rot and improves flavor. Blossom end rot, however, is caused by a calcium deficiency or irregular watering, not a lack of magnesium. Adding Epsom salt will not fix it, and it could even make it worse by competing with calcium uptake.

If you suspect a magnesium deficiency, look for yellowing between the leaf veins on older leaves. A soil test can confirm it. In that case, a small application of Epsom salt can help, but it is not a routine requirement. Most balanced fertilizers already contain magnesium.

Myth: Native Plants Are Always Better Than Non-Natives

Native plants are adapted to local conditions, so they often require less water and fewer fertilizers, and they support local wildlife. However, the blanket statement that natives are always better is an oversimplification. Some non-native plants have become invasive, but many are well-behaved and provide food or habitat for local insects and birds.

For example, many common garden vegetables and herbs are not native to your region, yet they are perfectly fine to grow. The key is to choose plants that are not invasive and that suit your site conditions. A well-chosen non-native can be just as beneficial as a native, and a poorly chosen native can struggle if it is not adapted to your specific microclimate.

The best approach is to prioritize natives when you can, but do not feel guilty about growing a few non-natives that are not invasive. Check with your local extension service or native plant society for a list of invasive species to avoid.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it true that you should not water plants in the sun?

It is not harmful to water in the sun, but it is wasteful because much of the water evaporates. The best time is early morning, and if you must water later, aim for the base of the plant to reduce evaporation and keep foliage dry.

Do coffee grounds really repel pests?

Some people claim coffee grounds repel ants, slugs, and cats, but there is little scientific evidence to support this. The grounds may have a mild deterrent effect due to their texture or smell, but they are not a reliable pest control method. Use them as compost instead.

Can I use Epsom salt to make my tomatoes sweeter?

There is no evidence that Epsom salt changes the flavor of tomatoes. Sweetness is primarily determined by the variety and the amount of sunlight and water the plant receives. If you want sweeter tomatoes, choose a sweet variety and let them ripen fully on the vine.

Why do some people say to plant marigolds to keep bugs away?

Marigolds contain compounds that are toxic to some soil-dwelling nematodes, and their scent may confuse or repel certain insects. However, they do not repel all pests, and some insects, like spider mites, are actually attracted to them. They are a good companion plant, but not a guaranteed pest solution.

Is it bad to till the soil every year?

Tilling can be beneficial for breaking up compacted soil, but frequent tilling disrupts soil structure and harms beneficial organisms like earthworms and mycorrhizal fungi. Many gardeners now use no-till methods, adding compost on top and letting the soil life do the work. It is better to till only when necessary, such as when starting a new bed.