Reported Speech for Requests and Commands

Reported speech for requests and commands uses verbs like ask, tell, or order followed by an object and a to-infinitive, not a that-clause. For example, “Please sit down” becomes “She asked me to sit down,” and “Stand up!” becomes “He told me to stand up.”

What Makes Requests and Commands Different

In English grammar, reported speech (also called indirect speech) usually shifts tenses, pronouns, and time expressions when you report what someone said. But requests and commands follow a simpler pattern because they are not statements of fact; they are directives. Instead of using say or tell with a that-clause, you use a reporting verb plus an object pronoun (me, him, her, us, them) and an infinitive with to.

The key difference between a request and a command is politeness and force. A request often includes words like please or uses a question form (“Could you open the window?”). A command is direct (“Open the window!”). In reported speech, both become asked me to open or told me to open, but the choice of reporting verb reflects the original tone.

The Basic Formula for Positive Directives

For affirmative requests and commands, the structure is:

  • Subject + reporting verb + object + to + base verb

Examples:

  • Direct: “Please help me.” → Reported: “She asked me to help her.”
  • Direct: “Close the door.” → Reported: “He told me to close the door.”
  • Direct: “Finish your homework.” → Reported: “Mom told me to finish my homework.”

Notice that the object pronoun changes depending on who is being addressed. If the speaker says “help me,” the reporter says “asked me to help her” (if the speaker is female) or “him” (if male). Pronouns shift just like in other reported speech.

Negative Requests and Commands

For negative directives, you add not before the infinitive. The pattern is:

  • Subject + reporting verb + object + not + to + base verb

Examples:

  • Direct: “Don’t be late.” → Reported: “He told me not to be late.”
  • Direct: “Please don’t smoke here.” → Reported: “She asked me not to smoke here.”
  • Direct: “Don’t touch that!” → Reported: “The guard ordered us not to touch that.”

A common mistake is to say “He told me that I don’t be late” or “He told me don’t be late.” Both are incorrect in formal English. The infinitive with not is the only standard form.

Choosing the Right Reporting Verb

The reporting verb you choose conveys the tone of the original directive. Here are the most common ones and when to use them:

  • Ask – for polite requests, often with please or a question form. Example: “Could you pass the salt?” → “She asked me to pass the salt.”
  • Tell – for neutral or firm commands. Example: “Sit down.” → “He told me to sit down.”
  • Order – for very forceful commands, often from authority figures. Example: “Leave the room immediately!” → “The teacher ordered us to leave the room immediately.”
  • Command – similar to order, but slightly more formal. Example: “Advance!” → “The officer commanded the troops to advance.”
  • Request – formal and polite, often used in writing. Example: “Please submit your report by Friday.” → “The manager requested us to submit our report by Friday.”

You can also use beg, urge, warn, or advise when the directive carries an emotional or advisory tone. For example, “Don’t go alone” could be reported as “He warned me not to go alone.”

Reporting Questions That Are Really Requests

Sometimes a request is phrased as a question, such as “Can you help me?” or “Would you mind closing the window?” In reported speech, you do not use question word order. You use the same infinitive pattern:

  • Direct: “Can you help me?” → Reported: “She asked me to help her.”
  • Direct: “Could you open the window?” → Reported: “He asked me to open the window.”
  • Direct: “Would you mind waiting?” → Reported: “She asked me to wait.”

Notice that the original question’s auxiliary verbs (can, could, would) disappear. You only keep the main verb in the infinitive form. This is a common point of confusion for learners who try to keep the auxiliary.

Pronoun and Time Expression Changes

Like all reported speech, pronouns and time expressions may need to shift to reflect the new context. For example:

  • Direct: “Please call me tomorrow.” → Reported: “She asked me to call her the next day.”
  • Direct: “Come here now.” → Reported: “He told me to go there then.”

Here, me becomes her, tomorrow becomes the next day, here becomes there, and now becomes then. These changes depend on the reporting situation. If you report on the same day, you might keep tomorrow. If you report later, you shift it.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Several errors are typical when learners report requests and commands:

  • Using that-clauses: “She said that to sit down” is wrong. Use “She told me to sit down.”
  • Omitting the object: “He asked to sit down” means he asked for permission for himself, not that he asked someone else to sit. Always include the object pronoun.
  • Forgetting not in negatives: “He told me don’t be late” is incorrect. Use “He told me not to be late.”
  • Keeping question form: “She asked me could I help” is wrong. Use “She asked me to help.”
  • Mixing up say and tell: You can say “He said to sit down” (less common but acceptable), but “He said me to sit down” is wrong. Tell requires an object; say does not.

To avoid these, practice converting direct commands into reported speech by first identifying the verb, the object, and the infinitive. Write the pattern out until it feels natural.

When to Use Say Instead

Although tell and ask are the most common, say can also be used with an infinitive, but it is less common and sounds slightly awkward. For example, “He said to sit down” is grammatically correct but less natural than “He told me to sit down.” In everyday speech, say is rarely used for direct commands. It is more common in written instructions or formal contexts.

If you want to report a command without specifying the listener, you can use say + to + verb: “The sign says to turn left.” Here, the object is implied. However, for most conversational situations, tell or ask is the better choice.

Reported Speech in Academic and Professional Writing

In college essays, emails, or professional reports, you often need to report instructions from professors, supervisors, or colleagues. The same rules apply. For example:

  • “The professor asked us to submit the essay by Friday.”
  • “My supervisor told me not to include raw data in the appendix.”
  • “The lab manual instructs students to wear goggles at all times.”

In formal writing, you might also use verbs like instruct, direct, or require. These follow the same pattern: instructed us to, directed them to, required us to. Note that require can also take a that-clause with a subjunctive (“required that we submit”), but the infinitive form is simpler and more common.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use “said to” instead of “told to”?

Yes, “said to” is grammatically correct but less common. For example, “He said to me to sit down” is awkward; most speakers would say “He told me to sit down.” In writing, “said to” can sound formal or old-fashioned. Stick with tell for commands and ask for requests.

How do I report a command that uses “let’s”?

“Let’s” is a suggestion, not a command. To report it, you can use suggest + gerund or suggest that + subject + base verb. For example, “Let’s go to the library” becomes “She suggested going to the library” or “She suggested that we go to the library.” Do not use the infinitive pattern for suggestions.

What about reported speech for “please” in a command?

If the original includes “please,” it is a request, so use ask. For example, “Please close the door” becomes “She asked me to close the door.” If you use tell, it sounds like a command without politeness: “She told me to close the door.”

Do I always need to change the tense?

For requests and commands, you do not change the tense because there is no tense in the infinitive. The reporting verb (asked, told) is in the past, but the infinitive stays the same. This is simpler than reporting statements, where you often backshift the tense.

Can I report a command without an object?

Yes, if the listener is obvious or generic. For example, “The sign says to turn left” has no object. But in most cases, you need an object to clarify who was addressed. Without it, the sentence can be ambiguous.

Summary

Reported speech for requests and commands is straightforward once you learn the pattern: reporting verb + object + to-infinitive. Use ask for polite requests, tell for neutral commands, and order or command for forceful directives. Add not before the infinitive for negatives. Avoid that-clauses and keep the object pronoun. With practice, you can convert any direct request or command into natural reported speech.