You can order a heart shaped pizza from many national and local pizzerias, especially around Valentine’s Day, anniversaries, or other special occasions. Major chains like Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, and California Pizza Kitchen often offer heart shaped pizzas for a limited time, while some independent pizzerias will make them on request year-round. Knowing where and how to order, what to expect, and how to customize your order can help you get the perfect heart shaped pizza for your celebration or gift.
Background: The Rise of Heart Shaped Pizzas
Heart shaped pizzas have become a popular novelty food, especially in the United States. While the precise origin is unclear, their popularity has surged in the last decade as pizzerias look for creative ways to boost sales during holidays like Valentine’s Day and Mother’s Day. Social media has also played a major role, with customers sharing photos of their festive pizzas, prompting more restaurants to offer them.
Originally, heart shaped pizzas were a rare specialty, often available only from boutique or gourmet pizzerias. Today, they are widely accessible, with both large chains and independent shops offering them as a fun twist on the classic pizza pie.
Where to Order Heart Shaped Pizza
Several national pizza chains offer heart shaped pizzas, usually for a limited time. Here are some of the most common options:
- Papa John’s: Frequently offers heart shaped pizzas during Valentine’s Day. The promotion typically lasts for about two weeks in February. Availability may vary by location.
- Papa Murphy’s: Known for their take-and-bake model, they offer the “HeartBaker” pizza around Valentine’s Day. Customers pick up the uncooked pizza and bake it at home.
- Pizza Hut: Has offered heart shaped pizzas as a limited-time promotion in the past, especially in the U.S. and Canada.
- California Pizza Kitchen: Some locations offer heart shaped pizzas during special events or for catering orders.
- Local pizzerias: Many independently owned pizza shops are willing to make a heart shaped pizza by request, even when it’s not on the menu.
It’s important to check with your local branch or shop ahead of time, as not all locations participate in these promotions and some require advance notice.
How to Order: Steps and Tips
Ordering a heart shaped pizza is usually straightforward, but there are a few steps to ensure you get exactly what you want:
- Check availability: Visit the pizzeria’s website or call to confirm they offer heart shaped pizzas and if any special conditions apply (such as only during certain holidays).
- Choose your toppings: Most places allow you to customize the toppings just like a regular pizza, but some may have set options for heart shaped pies.
- Place your order in advance: Especially around holidays, these pizzas can be in high demand. Ordering ahead helps ensure you get one.
- Specify the heart shape: If ordering from a local shop, clearly state that you want a heart shaped pizza, as it may not be a standard menu item.
- Pick up or delivery: Some pizzerias offer delivery, while others may require you to pick up the pizza, especially if it’s a take-and-bake option.
For online orders through a chain, look for a dedicated section or promotional banner. If ordering by phone or in person, confirm the details with the staff to avoid mix-ups.
Customization and Special Requests
Most pizzerias let you customize your heart shaped pizza much like a traditional pizza. Common options include:
- Choice of crust (thin, regular, gluten-free, etc.)
- Selection of sauces (tomato, white sauce, pesto)
- Variety of cheeses
- Meat toppings (pepperoni, sausage, chicken, etc.)
- Vegetable toppings (peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives, etc.)
Some shops get creative with presentation, such as arranging pepperoni or vegetables in a heart pattern, or spelling out messages with toppings. For birthdays, anniversaries, or proposals, you can sometimes request a custom message written with sauce or toppings.
Note that certain customizations may not be possible if the heart shape limits the size or structure of the pizza. For example, deep-dish or stuffed crust pizzas are less commonly made in heart shapes due to the dough’s rigidity.
Comparisons: Chains vs. Local Pizzerias
There are pros and cons to ordering from a national chain versus a local pizzeria:
- Chains: Easier ordering process, reliable consistency, often have online ordering and delivery. However, limited to specific promotional periods and fewer customization options.
- Local pizzerias: More flexibility for special requests, available year-round in some cases, and the chance to support a small business. Quality and style can vary, and you may need to call ahead or pick up in person.
If you have a favorite local pizza shop, it’s worth asking if they can make a heart shaped pizza even if it’s not advertised.
Costs and Value
The price for a heart shaped pizza varies depending on the pizzeria, size, and toppings. Generally, expect to pay about the same as a medium or large specialty pizza, though some shops add a small premium (typically $1–$5 more) for the custom shape and extra labor. As of 2024, typical prices for heart shaped pizzas in the U.S. range from $10 to $20 at major chains, with gourmet or custom options running higher at some independent pizzerias.
Promotional deals often bundle the heart shaped pizza with desserts, drinks, or sides, which can add value for celebratory occasions. Be sure to check for coupons or special offers, especially around Valentine’s Day.
Food Safety and Storage
Heart shaped pizzas are made from the same ingredients and cooked in the same ovens as standard pizzas. As with all pizza, ensure it is cooked to an internal temperature of at least 165°F (74°C) for food safety. Leftovers should be cooled within two hours, refrigerated in airtight containers, and eaten within 3–4 days, according to USDA guidelines. Reheat leftovers to at least 165°F before eating.
For take-and-bake options like those from Papa Murphy’s, follow the baking instructions carefully to ensure safe and even cooking. If you plan to transport the pizza before baking, keep it refrigerated until ready to cook.
Common Problems and How to Avoid Them
Ordering a heart shaped pizza is usually trouble-free, but a few issues can arise:
- Shape not recognizable: Some pizzas may lose their heart shape during baking or transport. Request a photo or check the pizza before leaving the shop if possible.
- Limited availability: Not all locations offer the heart shaped pizza, especially outside of peak holidays. Always confirm in advance.
- Customization limits: Certain toppings or crust types may not be available with the heart shape due to structural challenges.
- Delivery delays: High demand around holidays can slow down order fulfillment. Order early or choose an off-peak time if possible.
Communicating clearly with the staff and ordering ahead are the best ways to avoid disappointment.
Alternatives to Heart Shaped Pizza
If a heart shaped pizza isn’t available or doesn’t fit your needs, consider these alternatives:
- Make your own: Many home cooks shape store-bought or homemade dough into a heart before adding toppings and baking. Pizza stones or baking sheets work well for this.
- Heart shaped desserts: Some bakeries offer heart shaped cookies, cakes, or brownies for a similar festive effect.
- Other novelty pizzas: Some pizzerias offer other shapes (like footballs or stars) for different occasions.
DIY heart shaped pizzas are especially popular for family activities or children’s parties, as they allow for more creativity and personalization.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I order a heart shaped pizza at any time of year?
Most national chains only offer heart shaped pizzas during specific holidays, especially around Valentine’s Day. However, many local pizzerias are willing to make them year-round if you call ahead and request it.
Are heart shaped pizzas smaller than regular pizzas?
Heart shaped pizzas are usually similar in size to a medium or large pizza, but the shape may result in slightly less surface area. Ask your pizzeria for exact dimensions if size is important for your order.
Can I get any toppings on a heart shaped pizza?
Most pizzerias allow standard toppings, but very heavy or elaborate toppings may be limited to prevent the heart shape from collapsing or baking unevenly. Check with the shop for their specific options.
Are gluten-free or vegan heart shaped pizzas available?
Some chains and local pizzerias offer gluten-free or vegan crusts and toppings for heart shaped pizzas, but availability varies. Always check with the restaurant in advance if you have dietary restrictions.
How far in advance should I order a heart shaped pizza?
For holidays or busy times, it’s best to order at least a day ahead. For regular days, a few hours’ notice is usually sufficient, but policies vary by shop.
Can I have a heart shaped pizza delivered?
Many national chains and local pizzerias offer delivery, but some only allow pickup for special shapes. Confirm with your chosen location when placing your order.
Summary: Making the Most of Your Heart Shaped Pizza Order
Ordering a heart shaped pizza is a fun and memorable way to celebrate special occasions or simply surprise someone you care about. While availability and options will vary by location and time of year, with a little planning, you can enjoy a festive pizza that fits your needs. Whether you choose a national chain for convenience or support a local pizzeria for a unique touch, knowing how to order, customize, and care for your heart shaped pizza ensures a delicious and picture-worthy experience.